The X-Files “My Struggle II” Review (10×06)

22 Feb


The problem with the revival series is that it takes what would normally be covered over ~22 episodes and attempts to condense it to 6. There’s just no way six episodes of television can deliver some solid monsters of the week, tackle a huge new conspiracy, delve into character drama, and introduce new characters for a possible season 11. Chris Carter certainly tried, but he’s failed in many aspects. Here’s what I would’ve preferred: six episodes devoted to the mythology, or six monster-of-the-week episodes showcasing different genres and styles.

Alas, we get an awkward mashup of the two, and it builds up to a fairly lackluster finale that seems hastily put together. I don’t think it’s a terrible episode of television, but within the context of the season, it’s pretty disappointing (but ultimately unsurprising). Although it’s tighter than last week’s episode, it’s still all over the place, unfortunately separating Scully and Mulder and falling victim to the same problems that plagued the premiere.

The intent is to show how, in the words of the Cigarette Smoking Man, “the world is crumbling around us”. The intent is to create tension through the notion of an incredibly wide-ranging conspiracy, to capitalize on the idea of paranoia in relation to our relationships with the supernatural and with each other. As the Cancer Man tells Mulder: “I didn’t set out to destroy the world, Mulder. People did.” So, when the UFO drops down over the bridge at the end of the episode, it’s a reflection of ourselves, concentrated in the eye of a woman who is now responsible for salvation.

Is William on the ship? Who knows? The fact that we end on a cliffhanger is slightly infuriating, but I’m not really surprised considering the episode didn’t really know what it was doing as it progressed. I’m hoping that in potential future seasons, there’s a better and more well thought out purpose going in. Of course, this miniseries is still worth it because we got to see Mulder and Scully again. We got to listen to the opening theme and see more monsters of the week and enjoy another Darin Morgan episode. It was slightly disappointing, but it was also a fun ride.




-Always nice to see Annabeth Gish again as Reyes.

-I’d say my favorite of the season was “Founder’s Mutation”. That was The X-Files doing what it does best.

-That’s it for me! I enjoyed writing about the show over the last six weeks, and thanks to everyone who offered up their thoughts. If the show returns–please don’t be a Miller/Einstein spinoff–I’ll definitely write about it again.

Photo credit: Fox, The X-Files


4 Responses to “The X-Files “My Struggle II” Review (10×06)”

  1. Keith Noakes February 22, 2016 at 11:35 pm #

    I agree that 6 episodes did it a great disservice. I would have much rather have liked 6 mythology episodes or at least more than the 2 because it just felt rushed and there was no payoff. This episode was still a messy but I thought it was better than the first. I wasn’t surprised by the cliffhanger and I very much hope there will be another season. I’m pretty sure it won’t be 22 episodes but 10-12 episodes like on cable shows would be a lot better for the series plot-wise as there would be less filler. I agree with your series grade and if it does go further, it has to be with Mulder and Scully or they shouldn’t do it. It would be nice if they could get Vince Gilligan back in some capacity. I can always rewatch the original episodes in the meantime!

  2. peggyatthemovies February 23, 2016 at 1:07 am #

    Well I don’t completely agree..But you do make some good points and it was fun to have you writing up episodics so fast again!! I take it your back home as you reviewed it east coast time!! Again, I thought it was a bit more fun this time around with some good humour thrown in. While the cliffhanger was frustrating yes, you can take away from the final sentences what was going to happen etc. And I for one, would love the Miller/Einstein spin-off or continuation which ever it would be. I thought Ambrose & Amell were both great.

    • polarbears16 February 27, 2016 at 5:12 pm #

      Yeah, I definitely understand the cliffhanger more considering Carter said FOX without a doubt wanted more episodes.

  3. Ruben Veriato March 11, 2016 at 5:55 pm #

    Absolutely and I would ve been a lot happier, if these had been 6 monster-of-the-week episodes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: